$425,000
427 S Mayhew Street
New Buffalo, MI, 49117
ARTFULLY ENCHANTING COTTAGE on a huge Double Corner Lot! This private sanctuary blends rich character and nostalgic appeal on secluded, picturesque grounds within the City limits. Located just moments from Lake Michigan beaches, downtown shops, restaurants, and the Amtrak station. Enjoy the sought-after, walkable lifestyle that this premier Southwest Michigan lakefront community offers. This authentic 1930/40s cottage is filled with music, books, and charm, creating a warm and creative ambiance. The residence is offered as-is, and is ready for thoughtful restoration, renovation, or reimagination. Opportunities of this size and location are increasingly difficult to find. The double-lot configuration offers a chance to create a separate, buildable homesite. Additionally, the oversized two-story garage has the potential to be converted into a guest house. Many options to renew, envision, or create something truly extraordinary in the heart of New Buffalo.
Property Details
Price:
$425,000
MLS #:
26046543
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
1
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
Virginia Addition
Listed Date:
Sep 2, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
978
Total Sq Ft:
978
Lot Size:
17,424 sqft / 0.40 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1940
Schools
School District:
New Buffalo
Elementary School:
New Buffalo Elementary School
Middle School:
New Buffalo Middle School
High School:
New Buffalo Senior High School
Interior
Bathrooms
1 Full Bathroom
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Wood
Heating
Forced Air
Interior Features
Eat-in Kitchen
Laundry Features
Laundry Room
Main Level Bedrooms
3
Exterior
Architectural Style
Ranch
Construction Materials
Vinyl Siding
Garage Spaces
1
Lot Features
Corner Lot, Level, Wooded
Other Structures
Shed(s)
Parking Features
Garage Faces Front, Detached
Patio And Porch Features
Patio
Roof
Composition, Shingle
Stories
1
Waterfront Features
Lake
Financial
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$2,870
Mortgage Calculator
Map
Current real estate data for Single Family in New Buffalo as of Sep 24, 2026
57
Single Family Listed
92
Avg DOM
474
Avg $ / SqFt
$1,134,051
Avg List Price
Community
- Address427 S Mayhew Street New Buffalo MI
- SubdivisionVirginia Addition
- CityNew Buffalo
- CountyBerrien
- Zip Code49117
Subdivisions in New Buffalo
- Diamond Point
- Diamond Point Condominiums
- Forest Beach
- Holiday Hills
- Marina District/Bridgewater Place
- Michiana Shores Sub 1
- Michigan Shores Country Club
- New Buffalo Twp
- North Barton Mews
- Oak Hill Springs home sites
- South Cove
- Summerhill Cottages
- Sunset Shores
- Virginia add to Vil of New Buffalo
- Warwick Shores
- Whittaker Woods Phase 1
Similar Listings Nearby
Property Summary
- Located in the Virginia Addition subdivision, 427 S Mayhew Street New Buffalo MI is a Single Family for sale in New Buffalo, MI, 49117. It is listed for $425,000 and features 3 beds, 1 baths, and has approximately 978 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1940. The current price per square foot is $435. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in New Buffalo is $474. The average listing price for Single Family in New Buffalo is $1,134,051.
427 S Mayhew Street
New Buffalo, MI